Saint of the Day




« Who is Pope Benedict? by Cardinal Egan | Main | St. Photina (in Russian, Svetlana) »

The Catholic Mass and Luther's Mass

(Excerpts from lectures by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, 1975; emphasis in the original.)

(On the Catholic Mass) At the Last Supper Our Lord said, "Do this in memory of Me;" "Hoc facite im meam commemorationem." He did not say, "Tell this story, remember my sacrifice;"  He said "Facite," "Do this Sacrifice, re-do this sacrifice, continue this Sacrifice."

Protestants forget or refuse to recognize that Our Lord said: "Hoc facite," "Do this!"  They, rather, recall what Christ did at the last Supper: "in meam commemorationem."  They do not continue Our Lord Jesus Christ's Sacrifice.  The Blessed Virgin Mary teaches us, together with the Apostles, and with our Lord Himself, that we are to go unto the altar with the priest to offer the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, and that through the actions and the words of the priest Our Lord truly comes to the altar as the Victim truly present in the Holy Eucharist.  He in truth said to the Apostles: "Hoc facite," and we ought therefore to pray to the Blessed Virgin Mary for the gift of deep faith in the Holy Sacrifice of the altar.

(On Luther's mass) Let us examine the manner in which Luther achieved his reform of the liturgy, that is implemented the "evangelical Mass", as he himself called it.  Of particular interest in this effort are the actual words of Luther himself, or of his disciples, with respect to the reforms.  It is enlightening to note the liberal tendencies which inspire Luther:

In the first place, he writes, I would kindly and for God's sake request all those who see this order of service or desire to follow it: do not make it a rigid law to bind or entangle anyone's conscience, but use it in Christian liberty as long, when, where, and how you find it to be practical and useful.

The cult, he continues, was formerly meant to render homage to God; henceforth it shall be directed to man in order to console him and enlighten him.  Whereas the sacrifice formerly held pride of place, henceforth the most important will be the sermon.

... For Luther the substance of the bread remains.  Consequently, in the words of his disciple Melanchton, who strongly opposed the adoration of the Blessed Sacrament, "Christ instituted the Eucharist as a memorial of His Passion.  To adore It is therefore idolatry."

It follows that Communion is to be taken in the hand and under both species, which reinforces the denial of the presence of Our Lord's Body and Blood; it is thus normal to consider the Eucharist as incomplete under a single species.

Once again we note the strange resemblance between the present renewal and Luther's Reform.  Every recent promulgation on the Eucharist tends toward a lessening of respect, a retreat from adoration: Communion in the hand and its distribution by lay men and lay women; the reduced number of genuflections, which many priests have discontinued altogether; the use of ordinary vessels and ordinary bread, all of these innovations have diminished belief in the Real Presence as taught by the Catholic Church.

|

Comments (3)

Vicar Robert rainis :

Dear Brother in Christ:
Your understanding of the reforms called for by Fr Martin Luther are most unfortunate, incomplete and inaccurate. Luther did not "abolish the Mass" but to insure its apostolic heritage, indeed as the LORD Himself had initiated. We reject transubstanciation because it is a human attempt to define the Mystery of Mysteries, using an Aristotle formula.
God Bless,
Bob Rainis

Cyprian Author Profile Page:

Bob,

Thanks for writing and confirming what Abp. Lefebvre said, that Luther abolished what Catholics do. But what Luther concocted didn't exist in Christian belief and practice before him, so it couldn't be what the Lord instituted.

Hence, we are not "brothers in Christ," and at most one of us can share in eternal beatitude, not both. The sad part of this is that my own father chose to follow Luther into Hell. You have time to change, and you and all Lutherans have my prayers.

Vicar Bob :

Brother Cyprian;
The LORD spoke "Latin"????? The Holy Apostles spoke Latin??? The Evangelists spoke Latin. Thanks for correcting history, never mind the facts. And I pray that your Dad embrassed the love of GOD, through faith alone, by grace alone in CHRIST alone.
pax
Vicar Bob

Post a comment